Template-Type: ReDIF-Article 1.0
Author-Name: Mihály Hoffmann
Author-Email: hoffmannm@mnb.hu
Author-Workplace-Name: Magyar Nemzeti Bank (central bank of Hungary)
Author-Name: Gábor P. Kiss
Author-Email: kissg@mnb.hu
Author-Workplace-Name: Magyar Nemzeti Bank (central bank of Hungary)
Title: From those lying facts to the underlying deficit
Abstract: Developments in the headline budget balance are distorted by temporary factors. The most significant of these factors are the business cycle and creative accounting. Adequate information and estimates are available, allowing us to filter out these factors using a so-called adjustment for self-reversal. Expenditures and revenues adjusted in this way, however, continue to fluctuate, as fiscal policy measures can, in part, also turn out to be temporary in retrospect. We filter out this effect by using a four-year moving average (covering a full election cycle), instead of taking individual pieces of information into account. Moving averages are calculated in a forward-looking manner, for the three subsequent years in addition to the current year. This allows temporary effects in the past to be captured and renders their identification easier over the forecast horizon. Based on our results, the deficit indicators obtained using the adjustment for self-reversal and the adjustment for policy reversal are similar; the latter method, however, yields a higher deficit for the period 2010–2012, due to the tax cuts (phasing out of temporary taxes) announced for 2013. Overall, however, both adjusted indicators deviate substantially from the headline indicator, highlighting the significance of the adjustment.
Classification-JEL: E32, H62
Keywords: structural deficit, underlying deficit, cyclical adjustment, temporary measures, creative accounting
Journal: MNB Bulletin
Pages: 7-16
Volume: 5
Issue: 4
Year: 2010
Month: December
File-URL: http://www.mnb.hu/letoltes/hoffmann-pkiss-en.pdf
File-Format: Application/pdf

Handle: RePEc:mnb:bullet:v:5:y:2010:i:4:p:7-16